Can you settle student loan debt for less than you owe?

Student loan settlement means negotiating with your lender or servicer to accept a lump sum payment that is less than the current balance owed. In other words, you pay part of your debt in exchange for the lender agreeing to forgive the rest.

This may sound attractive, especially if your balance has ballooned due to years of interest or collection fees. But adjustments are very limited (especially for federal loans) and often come with long-term costs.

Here’s what to know about settling your student loans.

Can you settle federal loans for less than you owe?

Although you can technically settle your federal loans — whether they are FFEL loans or delinquent Direct Loans — it’s unlikely you will be able to. Why?Federal loans are money owed to American taxpayers.As such, Congress sets the rules by which you can settle, and there are many, many ways for the US government to followcan collect from youOnce you are in default mode.

They can garnish your wages, take your tax refunds, garnish your Social Security, or seek other federal benefits. They do not need court approval to initiate wage garnishment, as private loan holders do.

The truth is the Ministry of EducationIt does not issue any general guidelineson federal loan settlement because they don’t want to encourage anyone to do so.

However, the Department of Education issues internal guidance to its contracted collection agencies and assurance agencies. (Guarantee agencies are organizations that guarantee FFELP loans against default and often service them as well, such as AES.)

This is the Ministry of EducationGuidance noteThe Instructions to Guarantee Agencies since 1993 stipulate that guarantee agencies are permitted to “settle” or settle a loan under certain conditions and for certain amounts.

Permissible settlement or settlement offers are:

1. Exemption from debt collection fees
2. 50% exemption from interest and fees
3. 90% of the capital and interest

But assuming you decide to go this route, you should be prepared with a good offer to negotiate with the collection or escrow agency. And I realize this all depends on your current loan balance – Notice how none of the offers really discount what you’ve already borrowed.

Can you settle private student loans?

But private student loans are a different story. These loans work more like credit card debt — if you stop making payments, a lender or collection agency may be willing to negotiate.

When settlement is possible:

• The loan is in default or has been charged off.
• The lender believes that collecting the full amount is unlikely.
• You can make a lump sum payment (often 40-70% of the total balance).

example:

A borrower with a private loan of $20,000 in pools may come up with $10,000 in cash to close the account. The lender agrees, marks the debt as “settled,” and stops further collections.

While this can end debt, it comes with drawbacks:

• Credit damages: A settled account stays on your credit report for up to seven years.
• Tax liability: The forgiven balance is usually considered taxable income.
• Requirement to pay a lump sum: You’ll need to pay quickly, often within 90 days.

Strategic default for settlement

Some people consider defaulting strategically for the purpose of settling their loans. While this may be a strategy towards success if…EverythingIf things go wrong, you can easily destroy your credit score, open yourself up to litigation from your lender, and even not get what you want from your settlement deal.

You could rack up fees and interest along the way. You may still be stuck paying back the loan in the end. This is definitely more of an option for private loans, but we definitely don’t recommend it.

How to Start Negotiating a Student Loan Settlement

We don’t advise most people to try to negotiate this on their own – this is where you’ll want to get your student loan attorney involved. But if you do, here are some basic steps to get started:

1. Confirm the loan type. Use the Federal Student Aid dashboard (Studentaid.gov) to check whether your loans are federal or private.
2. Contact your service provider or collection agency. Ask whether they are authorized to negotiate and what settlement terms may apply.
3. Request all offers in writing. Never rely on a verbal agreement – ​​make sure the terms include the payment amount, due date, and language in which your credit will be cleared.
4. Consult a student loan attorney or certified financial advisor. Settlements can have significant legal and tax consequences.
5. Obtain proof of payment and closing. Keep records indefinitely in case the debt resurfaces.

Alternatives (which are likely better)

For most borrowers, settlement should be a last resort. Other options can provide long-term relief without hurting your credit score.

Federal Loans:

• Income-Based Repayment (IDR): The maximum payments are 10-20% of discretionary income and can lead to forgiveness after 20-25 years.

Private loans:

• Ask about temporary patience, Hardship programsOr refinancing options before considering settlement.

These programs often reduce or temporarily stop payments without requiring you to default, which helps protect your credit and financial stability in the long term.

What you should pay attention to

Defaulting borrowers are some of the most vulnerable to student loan scams. Make sure you keep an eye on these basic things:

• Debt settlement companies: Many advertise that they can “wipe out your student loans for pennies.” Most of them can’t. Avoid anyone who asks for upfront fees or guarantees.
• Tax surprises: The IRS generally treats forgiven debts as taxable income, unless you qualify for an exception such as insolvency. Run our tax bomb calculator to understand the impact.
• Default risk: Once you stop paying to pursue a settlement, your credit score can decline, and collection actions may escalate.

Always check offers with your loan servicer or directly with the Department of Education.

Instructions

Can you settle your federal student loans without defaulting?

No, federal settlements are only considered after a default, once the loan enters collections.

Are debts forgiven or paid taxable?

Yes. The canceled portion of a private loan is generally taxed as income, although insolvency exceptions may apply. Federal settlements may or may not trigger taxes depending on the terms.

Can I negotiate a payment plan instead of a lump sum?

Sometimes, collection agencies may accept short-term installment settlements, but lump sum offers are preferred.

How does the settlement affect my balance?

The loan will be reported as “settled for less than full balance,” which could lower your credit score for up to seven years.

Bottom line

It is possible to settle student loan debt for less than you owe, but it is rare, risky, and often unnecessary. For most borrowers (especially those with federal loans), income-driven repayment, forgiveness, or rehabilitation programs offer better paths to long-term relief.

If you are in default or overwhelmed by private loans, talk with your loan officer or student loan attorney before negotiating any settlement.

Don’t miss these other stories: