Increased early Gen Z 401(k) withdrawals.

In the workplace, the term “quiet resignation” has become shorthand for disengagement, where workers do their jobs but fall back on traditional loyalty to companies. Now, the same sentiment seems to be echoing in personal finance. Generation Z is quietly leaving their 401(k).

now, Automatic registration(PDF) It’s led to a surge in the number of Gen Z 401k participants — but they’re also making more withdrawals than ever before.

According to payroll integration 2025 Employee Financial Health Reportalmost 46% of Generation Z workers They have already withdrawn money from their 401(k) or IRA accounts. This is higher than any other generation – by a large margin. Among millennials, only 31% did the same.

The motive is not indulgence, but survival. on 42% of Gen Z who used their retirement funds did so to pay off debtCompared to only 6% of millennials. The result is a growing generation that views their retirement accounts more as a short-term safety net than a savings vehicle.

Focus on liquidity

Traditional retirement systems were built for workers who could keep their money for decades. But the financial reality of Generation Z doesn’t allow for that kind of patience.

A Goldman Sachs Asset Management Survey I found that more 70% of Generation Z He cited competing financial priorities (student loans, rising rents, inflation) as the biggest barriers to retirement saving. When everyday life requires money, tying it up in a 401(k) may seem unrealistic.

This pressure is exacerbated by declining cash reserves. the Retirement Across America Survey(PDF file) Reports The average emergency fund for Gen Z is just $2,000leaving a little buffer for unexpected expenses. For many, dipping into a 401(k) isn’t a lack of discipline — it’s the only option.

There is also an emotional component. Gen Z’s skepticism runs deep: Many question the long-term viability of Social Security and wonder whether employer-sponsored plans will hold up by the time they retire.

In other words, they are not convinced that the traditional system will deliver on its promises.

Rigid structures in a changing workforce

Even if Gen Z wanted to stick with the system, the 401(k) wasn’t a consideration.

The plan was designed for an era when workers spent contracts with a single employer. Today’s young professionals move jobs frequently, often across industries or to become self-employed.

The rise of self-employment and freelance work only widens the gap. Traditional 401(k) structures rely on employer matching, payroll deductions, and consistent hiring — all of which are rare in a workforce defined by side hustles, contract work, and career pivots.

Yes, there are Solo 401ks, but again, it depends on the individual setting up and contributing.

Social media “gurus” push alternatives

As Gen Z’s skepticism toward retirement accounts spreads, another online movement has rushed to fill the void: influencers who promote Life insurance as an “investment alternative”.

Across TikTok and Instagram, financial creators have promoted permanent life insurance and indexed universal life (IUL) policies as flexible wealth-building tools that “beat” a 401(k). However, many of these claims can be Misleading or predatory.

These phony financial advisors realize that there is competition for dollars: Young investors typically don’t have the extra money to fund both 401ks and IULs, so many unscrupulous salespeople push them as alternatives.

The basic promise (tax-free withdrawals and guaranteed growth) often obscures high fees, complex terms, and the fact that these policies are best suited for very specialized scenarios.

This clash between digital financial advice and traditional savings models highlights the generation gap: Generation Z is looking for flexible options but is often faced with products designed for a very different financial life.

Key takeaways for Gen Z workers

For young people, the data is alarming but useful:

• Avoid spending money if possible. The goal of a 401k is long-term growth. It’s not fun or exciting, but over time, it will turn into a huge nest egg.
• Create an emergency fund first. Even a few thousand dollars in savings can prevent retirement accounts from being tapped during a crisis.
• Ask for unbiased advice. Be wary of financial influencers who promote complex insurance products or promise “tax-free wealth.”

“Quiet withdrawal” from the 401(k) is not apathy, but rather a sign that traditional financial systems are not keeping up with modern economic realities. Until retirement plans evolve to support flexibility and financial uncertainty, Gen Z skepticism is likely to persist.

Don’t miss these other stories: